O
Maui County
← Community
GovernanceCommunity discussion

Kalawao County transition

Maui County

Summary not yet generated for this topic.

Community sentiment

Supportive (2)Opposed (13)Concerned (6)

At a glance

Public comments
21
Last 30 days
0

Last discussed Jan 29, 2026.

Public comments (21)

ConcernedDeGrey VanderbiltJan 29, 2026

Said the transition details have had almost no community discussion, questioned new NPS road-permit requirements, and called for more community meetings.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 25:06 →
SupportiveLaurie BuchananJan 29, 2026

Strongly supported county takeover, citing lack of oversight by DHHL and NPS and the county's history of showing up for Molokai emergencies.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 31:11 →
SupportiveMark AquinoJan 29, 2026

Wants Kalaupapa kept as a living community with cultural practices, fishing and restoration — not treated as just a cemetery.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 36:47 →
ConcernedPhilip KikukawaJan 29, 2026

Urged visitor limits, no new development, and keeping Kalaupapa as a hospice; praised the memorial effort.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 39:06 →
OpposedSharilyn KamakanaJan 29, 2026

Prefers a Molokai County over Maui County; wants the land returned to homestead beneficiaries.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 43:00 →
OpposedSibel LopezJan 29, 2026

Opposed the bill as a fourth-generation homesteader; urged the county to fix enforcement topside first and support a Molokai County.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 51:58 →
OpposedWalter RiddyJan 29, 2026

Supports a Molokai County; concerned about displaced families, Waikolu Valley water resources, and federal park control.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 54:28 →
OpposedKahekili PakalaJan 29, 2026

Spoke for the Kapaʻikea homestead association against the whole island becoming Maui County, citing Molokai's unique identity.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 57:30 →
OpposedCarol Lee KamekonaJan 29, 2026

Wants Kalaupapa to stay Kalawao County or become Molokai County, with an elected Molokai board overseeing decisions.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 1:00:05 →
OpposedYama (unidentified surname)Jan 29, 2026

Said Native Hawaiians and DHHL beneficiaries should hold their own separate meeting to decide Kalaupapa's future, citing lack of transparency.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 1:03:38 →
ConcernedHalona KaupuikiJan 29, 2026

Shared deep family history with the Kalaupapa lighthouse and Kalawao graves; urged protection of homesteader access and religious practice.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 1:10:12 →
OpposedMarlene Kamuela PurdyJan 29, 2026

Five-generation homesteader suggesting Kalawao be placed under DHHL as a state entity rather than Maui County.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 1:17:05 →
OpposedKalani Johnson Sr.Jan 29, 2026

Fourth-generation homesteader who wants the lands returned to Hawaiian Homes, saying beneficiaries have waited too long.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 1:20:20 →
OpposedPalmer NakiJan 29, 2026

Simple message: 'Molokai County, hundred percent' — time to control our own destiny.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 1:24:45 →
OpposedDickens StoneJan 29, 2026

Homesteader and waitlister opposed to Maui County takeover; wants involvement in water recreation and access.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 1:33:09 →
ConcernedMichelle PiscayaJan 29, 2026

Former NPS employee and descendant said the transition WILL cost money — trash, derelict vehicles, emergency services — and urged nitty-gritty community conversations.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 1:28:37 →
OpposedHala PakalaJan 29, 2026

By phone: asked for meetings outside work hours and said Molokai should become Kalawao County, not be swallowed by Maui.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 1:36:29 →
ConcernedLeimana NakiJan 29, 2026

Kanaka maoli testimony on ancestral ties to Makanalua and displacement of families to Māʻalaea.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 1:38:38 →
OpposedKainoa Le McDonaldJan 29, 2026

Speaking for Hawaiian homestead associations, urged a PAUSE on the transition until beneficiary consultation and trust/legal analysis are complete.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 1:45:06 →
ConcernedStacey Helm CrivelloJan 29, 2026

Asked who will govern DHHL/DLNR lands, whether Maui taxpayers will absorb enormous costs, and urged obtaining the state's transition plan.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 1:49:09 →
OpposedLuan FaberitoJan 29, 2026

Third-generation homesteader standing in solidarity with Molokai voices to keep Kalawao County as is.

Kōmike Aloha ʻĀina (2025-2027) — January 29, 2026 · 1:57:19 →